The latest episode of Mythic Quest Season 4, titled “The Villain’s Feast,” takes us on a chaotic ride through a murder mystery party that quickly spirals into deception, pranks, and unexpected revelations.
Just when the whole Ian-Poppy dynamic started feeling repetitive, this episode injected fresh drama, hilarious moments, and a bombshell ending that could redefine the characters’ future.
But what exactly happened, and what does it all mean? Let’s break it down.
Who Hosted the Murder Mystery?
The episode kicks off with the Mythic Quest gang arriving at a lavish private island for a murder mystery party. The mastermind behind the game is unknown, leading to speculation among the group.

Poppy, ever the skeptic, assumes it’s Ian, thinking it’s some elaborate scheme for him to get closer to her new love interest, Storm. But Ian vehemently denies it, adding layers to the mystery.
As the game progresses, things take a comedic yet chaotic turn. The first “victim” of the game is Brad, and soon, the group realizes that even Jo—the designated game mistress – has no clue who’s pulling the strings. This turns the murder mystery into something far more intriguing: Who is the real host, and what’s their endgame?
Ian, Storm, and the Prank That Backfired
As expected, Ian and Storm finally get a chance to talk, but their conversation quickly takes a twist. Storm, playing the cool and collected outsider, tells Ian that his relationship with Poppy is nothing more than a casual fling. He even asks Ian to keep this from Poppy, citing the infamous “bro code.”

Ian, true to his impulsive nature, does the exact opposite. Watching Poppy and Storm get cozy irks him, so he bluntly tells Poppy that Storm sees her as a mere fling. Poppy dismisses Ian’s claims, but things escalate when Ian accuses Storm of flirting with Jo. To his surprise, Storm admits it – but it turns out to be harmless fun.
But here’s the kicker: Poppy and Storm were pranking Ian the whole time. The entire setup was meant to teach Ian a lesson about interfering in Poppy’s personal life. And just like that, Ian finds himself eliminated from the game, not because he was the murderer, but because he couldn’t help but meddle.
Who was The Real Murderer?
As the game winds down, Storm becomes the final victim, bringing the mystery to its climax. The big reveal? The true host of the party was someone no one expected – Jo, who orchestrated the whole thing for her own amusement.

But while the mystery gets its resolution, it’s the emotional fallout that leaves the biggest impact. Ian, shaken by the prank, surprisingly admits that it made him like Storm more. He recognizes that he crossed a line and genuinely tries to make amends.
In a rare moment of vulnerability, he even gives his blessing to Poppy and Storm’s relationship. But here’s where it gets interesting – Poppy doesn’t want his blessing. She insists that what she and Storm have is just a casual fling, revealing that Storm is moving to the Netherlands for work. But is that truly how she feels, or is she hiding something deeper?
A Surprise Proposal and a Jaw-Dropping Ending
Just when we think the episode is wrapping up, it drops not one, but two massive surprises. First, a completely unexpected marriage proposal shakes up the group, adding an extra layer of drama. But even more shocking? Poppy might be pregnant.

Yes, you read that right. The episode subtly hints at a possible pregnancy, which, if true, could change everything for both Poppy and Ian.
Could this be the real reason she seemed unsettled throughout the night? Could this be why she pranked Ian – to see how he would react in a high-pressure situation?
What Does This Ending Mean for Mythic Quest?
Mythic Quest has always thrived on its character dynamics, and this episode proves that the Ian-Poppy relationship still has plenty of layers to explore.

While their love-hate dynamic has grown predictable, the new elements – Poppy’s potential pregnancy, Storm’s departure, and Ian’s unexpected moment of maturity – set the stage for an exciting shift.
Final Thoughts, Final Questions
With the murder mystery over, the real question remains: What happens next? Will Ian and Poppy finally have a real conversation about their future? Will Storm’s exit leave a void, or will it pave the way for deeper character development? And most importantly – who’s getting married?
One thing’s for sure: Mythic Quest just threw a massive curveball, and we can’t wait to see how it plays out.
About Mythic Quest
Mythic Quest is an American comedy streaming television series created by Charlie Day, Megan Ganz, and Rob McElhenney for Apple TV+. The series first premiered on February 7, 2020, and has two seasons so far. The show was renewed for seasons 3 and 4 in October 2021.
The series follows a fictional video game studio that produces a popular MMORPG called Mythic Quest and the challenges of the team to keep it afloat.
The series stars Rob McElhenney, Ashly Burch, David Hornsby, Charlotte Nicdao, and Danny Pudi. Season 3 will premiere on Apple TV on November 11, 2022.
No Comments on Mythic Quest Season 4 Episode 4 Ending Explained: A Murder or a Prank?