Mayfair Witches Season 2: A Spellbinding Return or Just Another Curse?

Dark magic, family secrets, and a thirst for revenge – Mayfair Witches season 2 has taken AMC’s Immortal Universe to thrilling new heights.

With Alexandra Daddario’s Rowan embracing her power and new cast members shaking things up, the series builds upon Anne Rice’s haunting legacy. But does it finally live up to expectations?

Is Mayfair Witches Season 2 Worth Watching?

The Immortal Universe just got a little darker, and Mayfair Witches season 2 is at the heart of it. After a mixed reception in its debut season, AMC’s adaptation of Anne Rice’s iconic trilogy returned in January 2025 with a fresh take on its gothic world.

Led by Alexandra Daddario as the powerful Rowan Fielding, the show took another stab at merging supernatural intrigue with high drama.

What’s New in Season 2?

If season 1 was about discovery, season 2 is all about reckoning. Rowan, now fully aware of her lineage, isn’t just running from the dark forces that haunt her bloodline – she’s ready to fight back.

But with Lasher (Jack Huston) growing ever more dangerous and Ciprien (Tongayi Chirisa) caught in the crossfire, the stakes have never been higher.

One of the biggest additions of this season is Ted Levine as Julien Mayfair, Cortland’s sinister father, whose presence only deepens the twisted family dynamics. Thora Birch’s Gifford Mayfair and Alyssa Jirrels as Moira Mayfair also shake things up, bringing new layers of tension and vengeance into the mix.

The series isn’t just expanding its cast – it’s also doubling down on the eerie atmosphere and dark magic that made Rice’s novels so captivating.

Did Season 2 Improve on the Flaws of Season 1?

Season 1 of Mayfair Witches showed some promise but stumbled in execution. Critics and fans alike found the pacing too rushed, with plot twists taking precedence over meaningful character development.

Season 2 makes some improvements – most notably with Alexandra Daddario’s commanding performance, which has been widely praised.

The reviews reflect a step in the right direction. Rotten Tomatoes shows an improvement, with the score jumping into the 70s from the dismal 50s of season 1. Decider gave it a confident “stream it” recommendation, thanks to Daddario’s portrayal of Rowan’s evolution from reluctant heiress to vengeful witch.

However, not everyone is convinced – Paste criticized the show’s continued struggle with pacing, while JoBlo found it underwhelming when compared to Interview with the Vampire’s refined storytelling.

How Does It Compare to Interview with the Vampire?

Being part of AMC’s Immortal Universe means Mayfair Witches is constantly going to be measured against its sibling series, Interview with the Vampire. And while Interview thrives on its rich character work and deep emotional beats, Mayfair Witches is still figuring out its identity.

The good news? Season 2 leans more into the gothic horror elements that make Rice’s work so compelling. The bad news? It still struggles with the breakneck pacing that leaves some characters feeling underdeveloped.

If you’re a fan of Rice’s books, you might appreciate the deeper dive into the Mayfair family’s cursed history – but if you’re looking for the same level of sophistication as Interview, you might be left wanting more.

What’s Next for Mayfair Witches?

With season 2 ending on a high-stakes cliffhanger, the question on everyone’s mind is: Will there be a season 3? AMC has yet to confirm, but given the improving reception, a renewal wouldn’t be surprising.

If the series continues to refine its storytelling while maintaining the dark, eerie appeal that makes it unique, Mayfair Witches could finally cement its place as a worthy addition to the Immortal Universe.

Final Verdict: Should You Watch It?

Mayfair Witches season 2 isn’t perfect, but it’s a definite improvement. If you enjoyed season 1, you’ll likely appreciate the deeper character exploration and gothic horror vibe this time around.

If you were on the fence, Daddario’s powerhouse performance might just be enough to pull you back in. And if you’re a die-hard Anne Rice fan? Well, you probably don’t need convincing.

With its mix of dark family secrets, supernatural horror, and a heroine who refuses to back down, Mayfair Witches season 2 casts a spell that’s hard to ignore. Whether that spell will last long enough for a third season? Only time will tell.

About Mayfair Witches