Peacock’s hit Based on a True Story returned with a vengeance on November 21, 2024, delivering a season that dialed up the chaos, dark humor, and tension fans loved from its debut.
This thriller-comedy hybrid starring Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina delves deeper into the messy, morally ambiguous world of Ava and Nathan Bartlett, making its second season an unmissable rollercoaster for true crime enthusiasts and casual viewers alike.
Here’s all you need to know!
What Happens in Based On A True Story Season 2?
Season 2 kicks off with Ava and Nathan trying to rebuild their lives after their true-crime empire crumbles spectacularly in the wake of Season 1’s finale.
Their ill-advised decision to collaborate with serial killer Matt – AKA the West Side Ripper – came back to haunt them in ways they couldn’t have imagined.
Criticism from fans and the internet spirals out of control, and to make things worse, Matt takes creative control of their podcast, leading to even greater chaos.
The sophomore season wastes no time plunging viewers into its twisted narrative. Ava and Nathan’s attempts to leave their criminal entanglements behind are hilariously futile, and with the return of Matt (played with eerie charm by Tom Bateman), the danger they face is amplified.
The new season also introduces more personal drama as Ava’s sister Tory (Liana Liberato) reveals she’s engaged to Matt. But can a serial killer ever truly reform? That’s up to what fans think and what the writers have in mind!
Who Returns for Season 2?
Based on a True Story Season 2 retains its core cast, with Big Bang Theory star Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina once again shining as Ava and Nathan. Their chemistry, both in comedic timing and dramatic tension, continues to be a major draw.
Tom Bateman as Matt brings a chilling duality to the screen—half charismatic fiancé, half cold-blooded killer—while Liana Liberato as Tory offers a fresh layer of familial dysfunction.
The teaser trailer released ahead of the season set the tone perfectly, showing Ava, Nathan, Tory, and Matt burying a body together. The ominous yet absurd moment highlighted the show’s knack for blending horror and humor. Tory’s apparent indifference to Matt’s criminal past hinted at deeper secrets and dynamics that unraveled throughout the season, keeping viewers hooked.
Does Season 2 Deliver on the Hype?
Absoltuely. The twisted relationships at the heart of the story remained the highlight. Nathan’s slow descent into darker territory brought fresh tension, while Ava’s increasing desperation to protect her family—even at the cost of her morals—offered compelling character development.
Season 2 of Based on a True Story didn’t just ride the coattails of its predecessor’s success; it took the story to darker, wilder places.
What’s Next After Season 2’s Explosive Ending?
Like the first season, Based on a True Story Season 2 ends with Ava and Nathan in an even worse predicament than before.
Without giving too much away, the finale suggests the couple may finally have to face justice—not only for their own crimes but for the havoc wrought by Matt as well.
However, just when it feels like the story might be wrapping up, the final moments leave the door wide open for a potential Season 3.
With unresolved tensions, secrets still lurking in the shadows, and plenty of questions about the characters’ fates, the show feels primed for another chapter.
Final Thoughts
Based on a True Story Season 2 cements the show as a standout in the crowded world of streaming content. With its dark humor, unpredictable twists, and stellar performances, it’s no wonder fans are already clamoring for a third season.
If you haven’t tuned in yet, now’s the time to dive into the hilariously twisted world of Ava, Nathan, and the West Side Ripper.
When it comes to combining crime, comedy, and chaos, Based on a True Story remains unmatched—and we can’t wait to see where it goes next.
About Based on a True Story
Based on a True Story is an American comedy thriller created by Craig Rosenberg, and stars Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina. The series premiered on Peacock on June 8, 2023.
The series follows Ava and Nathan, a couple who discover the identity of a serial killer. However, instead of handing him over to the authorities, they strike a deal with him by offering him a chance to appear on their podcast.
No Comments on Everything You Need To Know About Based On A True Story Season 2